- We got started quickly in class to make use of all their class time. Students followed as I explained on the board the major difference and similarity of the two men in question:
- One was an Italian Jew who was put into a concentration camp and had his young son with him, but he kept an incredibly positive attitude about his circumstances and kept his son unaware of the horrors that were going on around him. The point to understand for Guedo was that he was not in confinement for as long as Elie, the other man, nor in as bad conditions.
- Elie was a Polish Jew and was in a work concentration camp, separated from his sisters and mother, but had his elderly father with him. Elie’s attitude about his circumstances was very dark and negative, denying God’s existence at times and awaiting death and the end at every turn. His containment was longer lasting and he possibly lost more to those containing him.
- Students began watching La Vita Bella (Life is Beautiful) and enjoyed Guedo’s antics. I moved the video ahead to the part where they were being sent to the containment camp but, after a short while, my pc program started reading the dvd strangely. I stopped it eventually and explained part of the movie to students, relating how Guedo creates a whole imaginary setting for his son, pretending that the whole thing was a big game and they were the winners so far for not talking or holding out from eating for the longest. Students recorded some of their thoughts regarding the things that defined Guedo or influenced him towards his positive perspective.
- Then they began reading 7 pages of the non-fiction novel titled Night, by Elie Wiesel, a Holocaust survivor. In the reading, he struggles in waiting to find whether his father has been “selected” for death. It is a very dark and contrasting piece of literature, when compared to the comedic video of Guedo and his son.
- Tomorrow, they are to do another spelling test and have that reading selection finished. They will have a question sheet to work on individually, like a test, to see how well they can do at elaborating on their ideas and distinguishing the differences and similarities between the two stories.
Here is a key example of Guedo’s approach to his environment:
[kml_flashembed movie="http://youtube.com/v/EsEBoOS6zZo" width="425" height="350" wmode="transparent" /]
[kml_flashembed movie="http://youtube.com/v/9nAszZ74t10" width="425" height="350" wmode="transparent" /]